CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

Conflicts of Interest

JUMATISI (Jurnal Mahasiswa Teknik Sipil) is committed to maintaining academic integrity, transparency, objectivity, and fairness throughout the publication process. A conflict of interest, also referred to as a competing interest, arises when financial, professional, institutional, or personal relationships could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, the conduct, reporting, evaluation, or publication of a manuscript.

The disclosure of competing interests enables the journal to assess and manage potential conflicts appropriately. The existence of a disclosed conflict does not automatically indicate bias, misconduct, or grounds for rejection.

1. Types of Conflicts of Interest

Relevant financial and non-financial interests that must be disclosed include, but are not limited to:

  • Financial interests: Employment, consultancy, honoraria, research grants, stock ownership, patents, or other financial benefits related to the research.

  • Institutional interests: Affiliations, institutional commitments, or relationships with organizations that may benefit from the publication.

  • Personal and professional relationships: Family relationships, close personal connections, supervisory relationships, collaborations, or professional disputes that may affect impartiality.

  • Research and commercial interests: Relationships with contractors, consultants, material suppliers, technology providers, or other parties whose products or services are evaluated in civil engineering research.

  • Editorial conflicts: Editorial positions, personal involvement, or other relationships with JUMATISI that may compromise independent editorial judgment.

Ordinary academic disagreement or professional collaboration does not automatically constitute a disqualifying conflict. Authors, editors, and reviewers should disclose any circumstances that could reasonably raise concerns about impartiality.

2. Authors' Responsibilities and Disclosure

All authors are responsible for disclosing relevant financial and non-financial competing interests associated with their submitted manuscripts.

The corresponding author must ensure that an appropriate conflict of interest statement is included in the manuscript and accurately reflects the circumstances of all authors.

If no competing interests exist, the following statement may be used:

"The authors declare that they have no competing interests related to the publication of this article."

Authors must also disclose any funding or material support received for the research, including the names of funding institutions, grant numbers where applicable, and relevant in-kind contributions.

The Funding Statement must identify the role of the funder, if any, in the research design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, and decision to submit the manuscript for publication. If the funder had no involvement in these activities, this should be explicitly stated. If the research received no specific funding, the authors must declare this accordingly.

Funding disclosures do not replace the requirement to disclose competing interests. Authors must update their declarations if relevant circumstances change during the editorial and publication process.

3. Responsibilities of Editors and Reviewers

Editors and reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest before accepting an editorial assignment or peer-review invitation. They must also promptly notify the journal if a relevant conflict arises or is identified during the evaluation process.

Editors must not handle or make publication decisions on manuscripts in which they have a competing interest or direct involvement that could compromise impartiality. Such manuscripts must be reassigned to an independent editor or another appropriate editorial authority.

Reviewers must decline an invitation or withdraw from a review if a conflict of interest could reasonably affect their objectivity. Where necessary, JUMATISI will appoint alternative reviewers to ensure a fair, independent, and transparent assessment.

4. Assessment and Management of Conflicts

The Editorial Board of JUMATISI is responsible for assessing disclosed conflicts of interest and determining appropriate measures to protect the integrity of the editorial process.

Depending on the nature and severity of the conflict, measures may include:

  • Publishing an appropriate conflict of interest disclosure alongside the article.

  • Requesting additional information or clarification from the authors.

  • Assigning an independent editor or additional reviewers.

  • Replacing an editor or reviewer whose impartiality may be compromised.

  • Taking further editorial action when a conflict is found to have materially affected the reliability or integrity of the publication process.

Failure to disclose a competing interest or the submission of inaccurate declarations will be assessed according to the circumstances and the significance of the omission. Suspected cases of research misconduct or publication ethics violations will be handled in accordance with the journal's relevant research integrity and publication ethics policies.

Where a published article requires an update to its conflict of interest disclosure, JUMATISI will consider an appropriate correction or other editorial notice in accordance with its correction and post-publication policies.

5. Confidentiality and Editorial Independence

JUMATISI is committed to protecting confidential information obtained during manuscript submission, peer review, and editorial decision-making. Conflict of interest disclosures will be handled responsibly and used for the purpose of maintaining transparency and editorial integrity.

Editorial decisions must be based on the manuscript's scholarly merit, relevance to the journal's scope, methodological quality, originality, and compliance with publication ethics standards, rather than personal, financial, institutional, or commercial interests.

6. Reporting Concerns

Authors, reviewers, editors, and readers who identify a potential conflict of interest or a failure to disclose relevant competing interests may report their concerns to the Editorial Board of JUMATISI through the official contact information provided on the journal website.

All reports will be assessed fairly and confidentially, as appropriate, and handled in accordance with the journal's applicable publication ethics and research integrity policies.