PLAGIARISM POLICY

Plagiarism and Research Integrity Policy

JUMATISI: Jurnal Mahasiswa Teknik Sipil Universitas Muhammadiyah Metro is committed to maintaining originality, transparency, academic integrity, and responsible scholarly communication in civil engineering research and publication. All manuscripts submitted to JUMATISI must represent original scholarly work and comply with accepted standards of research integrity, proper citation, and publication ethics.

Submitted manuscripts may be screened for text similarity and other indicators of research-integrity concerns before or during the editorial and peer-review process. Plagiarism, inappropriate text reuse, data fabrication, data falsification, citation manipulation, and other forms of research misconduct are inconsistent with JUMATISI's publication standards and may result in editorial action in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement.

1. DEFINITION OF PLAGIARISM

Plagiarism occurs when an author presents another person's words, ideas, data, arguments, images, research findings, technical drawings, calculations, figures, or other intellectual contributions as their own without appropriate acknowledgment, citation, quotation, or permission where legally required.

Plagiarism may occur intentionally or through inadequate scholarly attribution. Authors are responsible for ensuring that all sources used in their manuscripts are accurately identified and appropriately acknowledged.

2. FORMS OF PLAGIARISM

Plagiarism includes, but is not limited to, the following:

  • Direct Plagiarism: Copying text verbatim from another source without appropriate quotation and citation.

  • Paraphrasing Without Attribution: Rewriting or summarizing another author's ideas, theories, methods, or findings without acknowledging the original source.

  • Mosaic or Patchwork Plagiarism: Combining sentences, phrases, or ideas from multiple sources with minor modifications without proper attribution.

  • Unattributed Technical Contributions: Presenting another researcher's structural analysis, engineering calculations, equations, design concepts, experimental procedures, or technical interpretations as the author's own work.

  • Improper Use of Data: Using another researcher's experimental data, laboratory results, survey results, numerical simulations, field measurements, or analytical findings without appropriate acknowledgment and authorization where required.

  • Improper Use of Figures and Technical Materials: Reproducing photographs, structural models, engineering drawings, charts, tables, maps, diagrams, or other protected materials without proper attribution and permission where required.

  • Quotation Misrepresentation: Reproducing another author's words without quotation marks or another appropriate indication of direct quotation.

  • Source Misrepresentation: Providing inaccurate, incomplete, fabricated, or misleading citations that obscure the origin of information.

  • Inappropriate Authorship Practices: Submitting work substantially produced by another person as one's own or failing to acknowledge legitimate scholarly contributions.

  • Inappropriate Text Recycling: Reusing substantial portions of one's own previously published work without appropriate citation, disclosure, or justification.

3. TEXT RECYCLING AND REDUNDANT PUBLICATION

Authors must disclose and appropriately cite their own previously published work when relevant material is reused in a new manuscript. Manuscripts submitted to JUMATISI must not contain substantial duplication of previously published articles, conference papers, or other scholarly publications without proper disclosure and editorial justification.

Limited overlap may be acceptable in certain circumstances, such as standardized descriptions of laboratory procedures or established engineering methods. Editors will assess the extent, location, context, attribution, necessity, and scholarly significance of the overlapping material.

Manuscripts that are simultaneously submitted to another journal or that duplicate previously published work without appropriate disclosure may be subject to editorial investigation and corrective action.

4. SIMILARITY AND PLAGIARISM SCREENING

All manuscripts submitted to JUMATISI may undergo similarity screening as part of the editorial assessment. The journal may use Turnitin and/or Plagiarism Checker X, or other appropriate similarity-detection tools, to assist in identifying potentially problematic textual overlap.

A similarity percentage is a screening indicator and does not, by itself, establish whether plagiarism has occurred.

Similarity reports are reviewed by the editor or an authorized editorial team member. The assessment considers the sources, amount, location, nature, attribution, and context of matching material rather than relying solely on the overall similarity score.

Reference lists, correctly quoted passages, standard technical terminology, mathematical equations, commonly used methodological descriptions, institutional names, and other legitimate matches may contribute to a similarity score without constituting plagiarism.

Similarity Indicator

As an editorial screening guideline, JUMATISI normally expects submitted manuscripts to demonstrate a low overall level of textual similarity. A similarity score of approximately 15% or higher may trigger additional editorial examination.

This percentage is not an automatic rejection threshold. A manuscript with a similarity score below 15% may still contain plagiarism, while a manuscript exceeding 15% may contain legitimate and properly attributed similarities. The final decision is based on editorial evaluation of the similarity report and the nature of the identified overlap.

5. OTHER FORMS OF RESEARCH MISCONDUCT

Research-integrity violations that may not technically constitute plagiarism are also considered serious publication-ethics concerns. These include:

  • fabrication of experimental data, laboratory results, field measurements, or research findings;

  • falsification or inappropriate manipulation of data, calculations, or analytical results;

  • inappropriate manipulation, duplication, or misrepresentation of figures, photographs, or technical images;

  • fabrication or falsification of references, citations, or digital object identifiers (DOIs);

  • citation manipulation or deliberate misrepresentation of sources;

  • undisclosed duplicate or redundant publication;

  • inappropriate authorship or contributor attribution;

  • manipulation of the peer-review process; and

  • deliberate misrepresentation of research methods, engineering calculations, laboratory procedures, ethical approvals, or research findings.

The use of artificial intelligence (AI) tools must comply with the journal's applicable policies on authorship, disclosure, and responsible research practices. AI-assisted writing does not exempt authors from responsibility for originality, factual accuracy, proper attribution, and the integrity of all submitted content.

Such concerns will be handled in accordance with JUMATISI's Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement and applicable publication-ethics guidance.

6. EDITORIAL SCREENING PROCEDURE

JUMATISI follows a screening procedure designed to assess originality and identify potential research-integrity concerns.

Step 1: Initial Screening

Submitted manuscripts may be checked using appropriate similarity-detection tools and other editorial screening procedures.

Step 2: Editorial Assessment

The editor or authorized editorial staff member evaluates relevant matched passages, cited sources, technical materials, and the context of any identified overlap.

Step 3: Author Clarification

Where necessary, authors may be asked to explain the identified similarities, revise the manuscript, correct citations, provide permissions, or submit supporting data and documentation.

Step 4: Editorial Decision

The editor determines the appropriate action based on the evidence, seriousness, and nature of the concern. Where appropriate, the matter may be referred for further investigation in accordance with the journal's publication ethics procedures.

7. ACTION BEFORE PUBLICATION

If plagiarism, inappropriate text reuse, or another research-integrity concern is identified before publication, JUMATISI may take one or more of the following actions:

  • request clarification from the author(s);

  • request correction of citations, references, or attribution;

  • require rewriting or revision of overlapping material;

  • request original research data, laboratory records, permissions, or supporting documentation;

  • suspend editorial evaluation while the concern is investigated; or

  • reject the manuscript if substantial plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, or other serious misconduct is established.

The action taken will be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the identified concern.

8. ACTION AFTER PUBLICATION

Concerns regarding plagiarism or research integrity may be investigated even after an article has been published in JUMATISI.

Depending on the evidence and seriousness of the matter, appropriate post-publication action may include:

  • publication of a correction or corrigendum;

  • publication of an expression of concern while an investigation remains unresolved;

  • retraction of the article when the published scholarly record is substantially unreliable or serious misconduct is established;

  • notification of relevant institutions or responsible authorities where appropriate; or

  • other proportionate measures necessary to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.

Any post-publication action will be handled in accordance with the journal's publication ethics procedures and applicable scholarly publishing standards.

9. AUTOMATED SCREENING AND HUMAN OVERSIGHT

Similarity-detection software and other automated research-integrity tools assist the editorial process but do not independently determine whether plagiarism or research misconduct has occurred.

The final assessment of suspected plagiarism, inappropriate text recycling, fabricated references, AI-related integrity concerns, or other potential misconduct remains the responsibility of the editor and, where appropriate, other qualified individuals involved in the investigation.

Authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, attribution, and integrity of their submitted manuscripts.

10. PLAGIARISM SCREENING POLICY SUMMARY

Policy Item JUMATISI Policy
Plagiarism Screening Conducted as part of editorial assessment
Screening Tools Turnitin and/or Plagiarism Checker X, or equivalent tools
Similarity Indicator Approximately 15% or higher may trigger additional review
Automatic Rejection Based on Percentage No
Editorial Assessment Human evaluation of the similarity report and manuscript context
Author Responsibility Originality, proper citation, and research integrity
Action on Confirmed Misconduct Proportionate editorial action, including rejection or post-publication correction or retraction where appropriate

Commitment to Academic Integrity

JUMATISI is committed to promoting originality, transparency, and responsible scholarly communication in civil engineering research. Plagiarism and research-integrity concerns are evaluated on the basis of evidence, context, and the seriousness of the identified issue rather than an automated similarity percentage alone.

Automated screening tools support, but do not replace, human editorial judgment. Confirmed cases of plagiarism or other research misconduct will be addressed through appropriate and proportionate editorial action to protect authors, readers, reviewers, institutions, and the integrity of the scholarly record.