- ABOUT THE JOURNAL
- Aims & Scope
- Journal Identity
- ISSN / E-ISSN
- Publisher
- Publication Frequency
- Indexing & Abstracting
- Contact Information
- EDITORIAL GOVERNANCE
- Editor-in-Chief
- Editorial Board
- Editorial Roles
- Ownership & Management
- Editorial Independence
- Governance Transparency
- Advisory Members
- FOR AUTHORS
- Author Guidelines
- Manuscript Preparation
- Authorship & Contributorship
- Originality / Plagiarism
- Preprint Policy
- AI Usage Policy
- Submission Requirements
- PEER REVIEW
- Review Teams
- Review Model
- Reviewer Selection
- Reviewer Guidelines
- Confidentiality
- Decision Process
- Revision Process
- Appeals
- PUBLICATION ETHICS
- Allegations of Misconduct
- Complaints & Appeals
- Conflicts of Interest
- Data & Reproducibility
- Ethical Oversight
- Intellectual Property
- Publication Malpractice
- RESEARCH INTEGRITY & CORRECTIONS
- Whistleblowing
- Corrections & Retractions
- Retractions
- Expressions of Concern
- Post-Publication Discussion
- Integrity Investigations
- Scholarly Record Updates
- TRANSPARENCY & BUSINESS
- Open Access Statement
- APC / Publication Fees
- Revenue Sources
- Advertising Policy
- Direct Marketing Policy
- Access Policy
- Sponsorship Disclosure
- POLICIES & PRESERVATION
- Copyright
- Licensing
- Archiving Policy
- Digital Preservation
- Privacy Statement
- Data Availability
- Repository / Preservation
Reviewer Guidelines
1. Before Accepting
Reviewers should accept an invitation only if they have the relevant expertise, can complete the review within three weeks, and have no conflict of interest.
2. Evaluation Criteria
- Relevance to the scope of Islamic Religious Education
- Originality and contribution (novelty)
- Clarity of the research problem and objectives
- Appropriateness and rigour of the method
- Accuracy of data, analysis, and interpretation
- Correct use and citation of Qur’anic verses, hadith, and Islamic scholarly sources
- Quality and currency of references
- Clarity of language and structure
3. Writing the Report
Reports should be specific, respectful, and constructive. Because many authors are students, reviewers are encouraged to explain how weaknesses can be improved. Personal remarks are not acceptable.
4. Recommendation
Reviewers recommend one of: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, Resubmit for Review, or Decline. The recommendation is advisory.
5. Ethical Concerns
Reviewers who suspect plagiarism, data fabrication, duplicate publication, or ethical problems should inform the editor confidentially instead of investigating themselves.




